Tác giả giữ toàn bộ bản quyền (All Rights Reserved) — không phải giấy phép mở. Bạn vẫn xem và học miễn phí trên OpenER; muốn tái sử dụng cần xin phép tác giả.
[SIDE CONVERSATION] DAN GARCIA: Welcome, everybody, to 61C, week 11 live session.
(CHEERING) Woo. Good to see you all.
BORA NIKOLIC
Good morning. Still trying to figure out how to get this thing going.
DAN GARCIA
This whole technology is new to Bora. So we're working on things. [LAUGHS] We're just having some fun. Let's see.
BORA NIKOLIC
Exactly.
DAN GARCIA
Okay, don't touch my window. Okay, I can un-spotlight you if you'd like. Anyway, welcome, everybody.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, please do while I'm fixing this.
DAN GARCIA
Okay, let me un-spotlight you. That way you can play with, in the background, remove spotlight. There, it's just me. Okay, anyway, good to see you all, as always.
Welcome to week 11, 61C. We're a week past the midterm. That's all water under the bridge. Looking forward, this week's material is OS, virtual memory, and I/O.
So this is our agenda for today. We have two guests.
We're delighted to have two guests join us, Sharon Mueller from Berkeley College of Engineering advising group and Krste Asanovic from Berkeley, and also the SiFive co-founder.
Happy to have him join us a little bit later.
We'll do Computing in the news, as we always do, and we'll talk about the week's plan, and always have an Ask us Anything Q&A time at the end.
So let me check the Q&A. Good, that stuff. All right, we're using mmhmm, by the way, for the anonymous attendee. That's how we're doing this.
It's not a Zoom thing, this is a special feature of mmhmm. All right, so let me introduce and let me spotlight you, Sharon, so you can get added here.
There we go. Let me introduce Sharon Mueller, who is the Director of Advising and Policy for the Engineering Student Services. Thank you, Bora, for reaching out.
And thank you, Sharon, for being able to make the time for our live session. We've got 43 students here. I predicted about 50. But many, many, many hundreds or so watch this.
And we are recording this — watch this a little bit later when they have the chance. I want to give you the floor. Certainly this is a remarkable semester.
It's a semester that has caused a remarkable amount of stress and just disruption among many, many students. This week isn't going to help us in terms of the chaos it's bringing.
But if you imagine just layer upon layer of just — it's not just COVID, it's COVID and I can't leave my house, and it's also online learning.
Like you can have no COVID but online learning. You can have an online course, you just do it in the middle of nowhere. But you have online learning on top of that.
You got the stresses of courses not giving flexibility. You've got fires and smoke, and I mean, right? Could you please — what's the Billy Crystal line from Princess Bride?
How about I give you a paper cut and let you pour lemon juice on it? I mean, could you really make it as bad? So thank you again for being here.
Thank you for all the hard work you do to have you and your team support our students.
Feel free to share some of the things that you can help them think about, how to be resilient, how to support themselves, where to reach out, all the resources that we have at the College of Engineering and campus-level.
People at different levels of crisis, from, oh, I'm feeling stressed, to I'm feeling a lot of stress, to oh my gosh, to whatever the final line is. Where do we do?
How do people know what to do, what the next levels are, and what bucket they fall into.
Well, if there's just a little stress, do I talk to — you know, who, ba ba ba, et cetera, et cetera. Plus planning for the spring, all that stuff.
You know that there was word about reducing class sizes and now I can't graduate. It's just layer upon layer upon all these things.
And UC Berkeley is in a hole of $450 million or something. So thank you so much, everybody, with the lemon juice all over my body.
So anyway, Sharon, please — welcome again, and feel free to share. And I'll un-spotlight myself and you can just take the floor and share your thoughts with the students.
Thank you so much.
SHARON MUELLER
Thank you so much for that introduction. You kind of stole my thunder there because I was going to mention all those things.
DAN GARCIA
Please do.
SHARON MUELLER
Yeah, so certainly, I think, what you touched upon is our emotions are heightened right now.
And I know this to be true for myself and everyone in my circle and certainly for our students as well. So I think it's important to recognize that that's normal.
That is a normal response to everything that you mentioned. But the benefits of being part of a big campus are that we do have a lot of resources to help students.
And I want to highlight kind of the big ones to help students out. It's OK if I share my screen?
BORA NIKOLIC
Yes, please.
DAN GARCIA
Yes, please.
SHARON MUELLER
It says I can't share me screen.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, no, no, share screen, all panelists, all you. It's all ready to go. It's all you. Yep, sorry for that.
SHARON MUELLER
Oh, there you go.
DAN GARCIA
Just fixed it. Just fixed it.
SHARON MUELLER
So here we go.
So I just wanted to highlight — are you seeing my screen that says Resources?
DAN GARCIA
Yes, beautiful.
SHARON MUELLER
Okay, perfect. All right, so I just wanted to highlight the resources that are available to all students.
Now, some of these, even though they're in the College of Engineering, I also want to mention that they are available to students in this class. Because EECS is within the College of Engineering.
So general well-being — I found an article at UCSF a while ago that I thought was super helpful in just normalizing the experience that we're all having, and also, beyond that, really gave some tools and tips on how to manage those feelings and what can
you do for yourself to kind of get you through this time. So if you want to read that article, I found it to be very helpful. So I wanted to share it.
In ESS, we actually have three psychologists who work within Engineering Student Services. However, they are available to all of you as well. And I put our website on there.
They have drop-in hours three days a week. And you are welcome to contact them at any time for support.
Also the CAPS, which is Counseling and Psychological Services, which is part of University Health Services, has even more counselors and social workers available for you.
I kind of look at it as coaching. Even Olympic athletes need coaching. And we're kind of in the Olympics of life right now.
We're kind of in the Olympics of trying to get through this race that feels like it's endless.
And so if you feel like you could really use some coaching and maybe some tools to help you get through your day and kind of think about what we're all managing and how to manage that yourself, I highly recommend reaching out to the counselors.
There's also a part of their website which just touches upon stress and anxiety management, just identifying what am I feeling, and then recognizing that there are things that I could do to help myself and what are those.
And then there's 211.org, which is if you don't want to use the university resources, you can go to 211.org.
And you put in your ZIP code, and you'll be connected to a whole bunch of resources in your local community. Now, we know that many families are also experiencing financial hardship right now.
The campus does have a Basic Needs Center and if you are having housing issues or food insecurity, they can assign to you a case manager who will basically get you connected to all of those resources.
The campus also has a Student Technology Equity Program that can help you.
If you're having issues — if your laptop is old and you need a new laptop, or if you need Wi-Fi or hotspots, you can apply for those funds.
And also financial aid is doing cost-of-attendance adjustments pretty regularly for students, recognizing that your cost of attendance may have changed and your financial situation may have changed.
So that's something that's available to you always. And also there are emergency loans that you can get through financial aid. Now, we know that all of this can lead to academic struggles.
And that's understandable that we all have a lot going on and it's harder to focus.
You might be under additional stress because perhaps you're feeling that this grade in your course is essential because you're trying to declare computer science.
Or maybe you're in the College of Engineering and you're trying to switch to EECS. So that can add another layer of stress. So some of you may find that you're overloaded.
And you may be in 13 units or 12 units, and you may feel overloaded. And that's fine. I know that Letters and Science is totally flexible with late drops this semester.
In fact, there's a form available to Letters and Science students on your My Academics class enrollment card in Cal Central.
You just have to fill out the form and you can drop one or more classes. In Engineering, we're also being flexible with late drops hours is a Google form.
The link is on this slide. And you just have to write a sentence or two about what you're challenged with as far as COVID-19 or remote learning.
And we're allowing late drops, we're allowing students to go below 12 units, which leads me to reduced course loads.
And all colleges now are being flexible because we understand what students are going through. And we know that, sometimes, you just can't carry the load that you would normally carry.
And then there's also the option of an incomplete grade.
And that's something that, if you've been making good progress in the course up until now but you're just feeling like you're not going to be able to finish all of your courses, that might be something that you want to talk to your professors about.
DAN GARCIA
We've already actually pre-approved everybody. If anybody asks for it, they get it, yes, without any questions asked. How about that for our policy?
SHARON MUELLER
Perfect. Yeah. That's great, that's great. So they have that in their back pocket.
DAN GARCIA
Exactly. [INAUDIBLE] And actually about 10 people asked for that already and have already been pre-approved, and get it, and no questions asked.
SHARON MUELLER
And so could they even email you?
DAN GARCIA
They don't email. It's just a form. There's a form online. They just fill in the form, and it's all done.
SHARON MUELLER
That's great, that's great, that's great. Because I know students don't want to drop courses. I mean, we're late in the semester. And they put in a lot of work.
And so that's a really great option for them. We just remind students, of course, they do have to finish it at some point.
And they have to be mindful that that's going to then add to their workload in the spring semester or during the summer. And so they should plan accordingly.
And we can work with those students on their course loads for those semesters as well.
DAN GARCIA
[INAUDIBLE]. I've also, by the way, promised to extend it as long as they need it. So many people say, we won't extend it past the next semester.
But I've already said, if you need the summer, you need next fall, however long it takes, I'll be here for you and allow them to extend to however long it takes for them to finish it.
SHARON MUELLER
That's great. And they just need to know that there is a form that they need to fill out with their college in order for us to do that on the back end.
DAN GARCIA
That's right, that's right.
SHARON MUELLER
All right, well, thank you very much.
DAN GARCIA
To extend it. They don't need a form — SHARON MUELLER: To extend it.
DAN GARCIA
Only for the extension, yes.
BORA NIKOLIC
Sharon, do you have time for a couple of questions?
DAN GARCIA
Yes, exactly.
SHARON MUELLER
Sure.
DAN GARCIA
Perfect.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, so the first one, the one that we are encountering, we have people who are abroad at the moment.
And they are often confused what does apply to them and what kind of help they can get when they're abroad.
DAN GARCIA
That's true.
SHARON MUELLER
Right. Do you mean as far as like an international student who's worried about course load because of a visa?
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, course load, related to visa, related to incompletes, related to mental health — DAN GARCIA: Support services too, yeah. I guess everything is remote, right?
So you're calling up different support levels.
SHARON MUELLER
Yeah, so all the support is available to them. It might not work so well for them because maybe it's in the middle of the night for them.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, that's a good point. Yeah, yeah, I didn't think about that.
SHARON MUELLER
A lot of the advisors are trying to hold evening hours or early morning hours to accommodate students who are all over the world. And I think there are some counselors doing that as well.
As far as resources, they're are all available to all students. With course loads, it depends on the student's visa and whether or not they're in an active visa status.
A lot of students aren't right now because they're not in the US. And so they don't have to be on their visa at the current moment.
We are advising students, however, that if they're applying for a visa to return, which likely they will be, they should check in with the Berkeley International office to make sure that taking reduced course load now wouldn't have any effect on their application for a visa for when we do come back to campus.
But there are also accommodations even for students who are on a student visa where they're allowed to drop below 12 units.
They just have to go through a process with the Berkeley International office in order to do that. And we have to sign off on it. But we're signing off on those all the time.
And so I know that a lot of students are doing that this semester.
DAN GARCIA
I don't think this is relevant for students who are getting incompletes, though, because an incomplete doesn't get triggered in the system until the end of the year, right?
Nobody would know. If they took an incomplete for this course, they stop doing their work in this course, they could breathe, they could finish the rest of the semester with all the other courses.
The incomplete wouldn't take — nobody would know about it until, boom, the grades are in in December.
SHARON MUELLER
Right.
DAN GARCIA
So that's not an issue for anybody. Anybody [INAUDIBLE] incomplete, don't worry about a course load, don't worry about, oh, it'll drop me below.
Because no one would know about it until the end of the year.
SHARON MUELLER
That's right. They're still in a full course load. Yeah.
DAN GARCIA
That's right. Even though they're not really, but they are. That's from the point of view. Yeah, yeah.
But the flip side of that is that, next semester, they still have to have their minimal course load on top of this course they're doing for no credit.
So it's a little bit of borrow from one — rob from Peter to pay Paul, where next spring, it's a heavier course load.
You're taking 12, but you're really taking 16, because — there's a little bit of that. So you need to maybe factor that into the decision process as well.
SHARON MUELLER
Right, right. That is part of the problem.
DAN GARCIA
But summer is out there. I mean, the summer is out there. I would say do it in the summer then. Because you have to have minimum course load fall/spring, but summer, who cares?
You can have a summer job. And you could be taking 61C in the evenings. I mean, you do whatever you want to in the summer. So I would say just wait till the summer.
Don't worry about the spring. I think spring is really hard. Just take it in the summer, you'd be fine. I think that's easier to do.
SHARON MUELLER
Yeah. I would say most students who get incompletes in the fall, if they have the opportunity to finish it over the summer, that's usually when they try to do it.
DAN GARCIA
Right. It might not be that much. It turns out, I mean, some people, they get sick and they can't hold their dinner down the day before the final.
They've done everything but the final. Then what they basically do is just take the final again. So that's not a lot of workload.
But it depends on how much work you have to actually still do for the next semester. Makes sense. Wonderful.
BORA NIKOLIC
There is a question that a student asked. Here is the question. So the UHS service only allows for three sessions free, which isn't enough for a lot of people in a very short term.
Are there any other resources for counseling if we can't afford otherwise?
SHARON MUELLER
So, I thought it was five sessions free unless they've changed it. And those are available to all students, whether or not they have the student health insurance plan.
And so it would depend on whether or not the student has that health insurance plan or not. Students who have the health insurance, then it's a co-pay.
And I think it's $15 per appointment at that point. And there are many practitioners in the community who serve Berkeley students for that same co-pay as well.
So I know sometimes the UHS counselors, it can be hard to get into their schedules. But there are many in the community as well.
If the student does not have the student health insurance, I think they have to have some kind of insurance. So they might want to look into their own insurance and see.
But there are also clinics that do sliding scales. And actually the CAPS website has a list of those on there as well.
Some, you can go for no money if you're in low income brackets.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, that's great. That's actually really nice.
SHARON MUELLER
So that's available to our students. And those resources are on the UHS Counseling and Psychological Services website.
BORA NIKOLIC
So your slide was great. Can we have it to post it — SHARON MUELLER: Yes. BORA NIKOLIC: --somewhere on our resource page.
SHARON MUELLER
I will send it to you.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, that's a great resource. It's a wonderful one.
BORA NIKOLIC
I think it would be a useful one to be actually put on the — somehere accessible to all the classes.
DAN GARCIA
That's a good point. That's a good point. Sure, yep, definitely.
BORA NIKOLIC
Thank you. That's a very good one-slide summary. Everything you need to know about advising and — DAN GARCIA: And the layers are important too. Folks, anybody else have any questions?
Sharon is such a resource. Anybody have anything else? Jump in into the Q&A or the chat very fast before we have to transition.
SHARON MUELLER
And I put my email in the slide. I'm happy if — students do not have to be in the College of Engineering to contact me.
So if they're in L&S, they can certainly contact me and I can get them connected.
DAN GARCIA
I actually learned something. I didn't know that, if you were taking an EECS course, which this course certainly is, you get access to the resources that are connected to that.
So that's a great — I thought, whoa, no, whatever your college is. Sorry, you don't have the special handshake for EECS. I didn't know that. That's great.
SHARON MUELLER
Including the Center for Access to Engineering Excellence, which offers free tutoring for anybody in our courses, and even in math courses or physics courses.
You do not have to be in the College of Engineering to get that.
DAN GARCIA
Outstanding. I don't know how the tutoring is working. I usually drop in the tutoring center. I don't know how the tutoring works online.
Maybe that's a little harder to do.
SHARON MUELLER
It is. It's still drop-in, but yeah, it is more challenging for sure.
DAN GARCIA
It's still drop-in on campus, you mean? So the only — SHARON MUELLER: No, it's drop-in online.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, drop-in virtual. I see. Oh, that's good to hear.
SHARON MUELLER
So they actually meet with someone first.
BORA NIKOLIC
Drop in a Zoom room?
DAN GARCIA
Wow.
SHARON MUELLER
Yes.
DAN GARCIA
Look at that.
SHARON MUELLER
Yeah.
DAN GARCIA
And you meet with somebody first, and connect and understand the system and how it works, and then you actually engage it.
SHARON MUELLER
Then they put you in the room, yeah.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, beautiful. That's good. Like a triagey kind of thing. That's good.
SHARON MUELLER
Yes.
DAN GARCIA
Nice, nice, nice. Well, I don't see any questions popping up. Thank you so much.
SHARON MUELLER
Thank you so much. Thank you for giving up the class time.
DAN GARCIA
Oh my goodness, no. This is a great — well worth the time. Thank you again [INAUDIBLE].
SHARON MUELLER
Thank you. Goodbye. Bye, everyone.
DAN GARCIA
Thanks for all you do, folks. Wonderful.
BORA NIKOLIC
All right, thank you.
DAN GARCIA
All right, we're back. All right, let me just [INAUDIBLE]..
BORA NIKOLIC
All right, we have — DAN GARCIA: We have our guest. We have our guest. Wonderful.
BORA NIKOLIC
We have a lot of guests.
DAN GARCIA
This is a good day. This is a good day. Krste, good to see you. Let me switch slides here so you can see it.
[INTERPOSING VOICES] DAN GARCIA: Do you want to do the introduction?
BORA NIKOLIC
I can say a few words. Krste has three full-time jobs at the moment. Each one of them is listed in PML less than 50% of the time, I guess.
So he's a Professor at UC Berkeley.
We mentioned him a few times when I mentioned the class, 152. So it's a good time to ask him about 152 now. I know a lot of students that are interested.
And there is an interesting situation that we are facing that I think both the class and the waitlist are full. So I think something will need to happen over there.
DAN GARCIA
That's great. Good to see the interest in 152. Wonderful.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yes.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
BORA NIKOLIC
So I think Krste will have stuff to deal with over the next few weeks or months.
But I think we need to unglue that one or get it unstuck so people can get at least on the waitlist. He is also one of the co-founders of SiFive.
But I think he spends a lot of time in the RISC-V Foundation, where he's the chairman of the board. And perhaps he can tell us a few words how he got here.
We usually ask our guests, how did you get here? How did you become a professor, the work you do?
Were you just born and then said, okay, I'm going to be a professor in Berkeley?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
No is the short answer. So it all started a very, very long time ago.
I think when I was a kid, growing up — I grew up in England, for one thing, so even though I have Serbian ancestry, I was actually born in England and grew up in England.
And growing up in a very small town in middle of England. And the school there, I was interested in technology and things. But this was very early days.
So like, for example, I think my school got one computer for the whole school. It was an 8-bit micro for the entire school. It was a Commodore PET.
And I was about the only person who had any idea what it was supposed to do.
And at the same time, I actually bugged my parents into buying me one of the very early 8-bit computers, a thing called an Acorn Atom, which was from the Acorn company in England.
And I was just fascinated by computers.
And this was a great machine for me, because they gave you the schematics, the whole electronic wiring diagram of the whole computer, and they also gave you — the computer had an assembler.
So you learn to program in assembler. So basically age age 14, 15, I was teaching myself assembly code and basic programming. And the reason I was into this was I liked video games.
So back then, it was one of these things where there was a traveling fair that would come to town. Once a year, in the summer, this fair would come to town.
And this one summer in I think it was 1979, they came and they had an arcade of the very first video games. So this was like Space Invaders, Galaxians.
And I thought, wow, what is this? You got to imagine, l you will play video games. I'm sure our friends do but this was like you're like 14, 15 years old.
And the first time you ever seen a video game. I'm like, wow, what is this thing?
DAN GARCIA
And you emptied your whole school budget, your whole college budget, on that probably, like all of us did. [LAUGHS] KRSTE ASANOVIC: Yeah, so I'm still paying back 10-pence pieces My poor mother.
Scrambled off with these 10-pence pieces when I went to play these games. And I was just fascinated. Oh, this is just amazing. How do they do this?
And the other unfortunate thing was this fad came and went, but then an arcade opened up literally about three minutes' walk from my house. And this arcade had all these video games in.
And I could just walk in there now. And I would spend too many late afternoons / evenings after school in this place, and too many 10-pence pieces.
But I got to know the owners of the arcade I was there so much. And then I started getting them to open the machines.
So I was looking in the back of these machines, like how do these things work. GARCIA: Wow. Wow.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
They rolled them up, and I'd see all these circuit boards and — DAN GARCIA: Wow. KRSTE ASANOVIC: --everything. I'd be like, this is pretty interesting.
I started reading up about it, and that's kind of what got me into computers was figuring out how these video games work.
So I wanted to learn how to write video games, so I got the little computer. So I started programming.
And the thing was, after I got into writing games, I really didn't play the games that much. It was more fun writing them than playing them.
But I was also interested in the process, how you build that. Why did they pick this design for that? Why did the 6502 have the a, x, and y registers?
Why were there only these instructions, not these other instructions? I was still getting my head around this. As this is an equivalent of high school, I guess. I had this computer.
I remember I had one computer, my school had one computer. And that was it. And then during high school we had dial-in access to a PDP-11 in the next town.
So this town was eight miles away, and I think it was like a 9K6 board modem that connected our school to this computer eight miles away, and all these terminals were hanging off this PDP-11.
I learned to program on the mini computer. So this was also fun. And so I was very interested in computers at that age.
But then I went to college, I went to Cambridge as an undergrad, and I did electrical engineering, because computer science wasn't a serious subject yet.
So the attitude then was, oh, computer science is just the thing you do off to the side, but the serious stuff is engineering. So I have engineering degree specializing in electrical engineering.
And at Cambridge, at the time, the people who did computer science were considered the failures.
Like if you couldn't do physics, or chemistry, or biology, after the first year you would go off and do the final two years would be a computer science degree.
DAN GARCIA
That's so funny.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Yeah, and also, if you really failed, you spent two years doing something else, then there was a one year consolation degree in computer science you could get.
So I didn't do computer science, at the time, as a degree because it wasn't considered a serious subject yet. You couldn't do an entire three year [INAUDIBLE] for three years.
You couldn't do a complete three degree just in computer science. I did electrical engineering.
I think that was actually a good choice for me, because I learned a lot about voltages, currents, the physical side of things, which I'm interested in computer architecture.
It's very important to understand how to build real machines. And also my thinking at the time was, this computing software side of things is kind of easy.
I've been doing it for a long time, whereas electrical stuff, that was hard, I didn't know that. So I wanted to learn — it's this stuff I didn't know.
So I was excited to go learn about how to build circuits and do complex math and things that I needed for that side of stuff.
So the other thing that happened to me was, while I was going to university I was sponsored by a company called GEC. This was the British company GEC, not the US company GE.
And the British company GEC, they had a sponsorship program, and they had a Research Center in London, Wembley, there where the big football stadium is.
So I used to have to go there in the summers for internships and also, part of the deal was I had to go work there after I graduated.
So I finished my undergrad, then went to work with them. And what I went to work on was a big fifth generation computer architecture project.
So they put me on a big the [INAUDIBLE] European research project in computer architecture. And that's what really got me more interested in computer architecture.
So I started reading these papers from these guys at Berkeley and Stanford about risking. It was all like, oh, this is really cool stuff.
So after undergrad, basically, working on a computer architecture research project, working on a chip design, that's when I got really into doing all this.
And at the time I thought, well, this is really cool. I want to do more of this. And when I left undergrad, I was 100% certain I did not want to do a PhD.
I just want to go build stuff, do real things. Because in England, you have to realize that PhDs were considered more ivory tower and academic. And I wanted to go build stuff.
I like making things.
But after a couple of years working in this research project, reading these papers from Berkeley, and Stanford, and other places, I was like, yeah, this is exciting, but I want to do a PhD in the states.
Like I didn't want to do it in the UK, it didn't sound like fun. So I applied to all these schools, well, a few schools.
I picked Stanford, Berkeley, MIT and Caltech, were the four that I applied to. And Berkeley and Stanford were my top two choices because I'd read the papers from Hennessy and Patterson.
So that's why I was excited to go there. And I got into Berkeley. I was very lucky. That was my first choice.
And remember I got an offer that included being a GSI in my first semester at Berkeley. So I came to grad school in Berkeley. Arriving in Berkeley is my first time arriving in America.
So I came to Berkeley to go to school. And I'm like, where's the beach?
DAN GARCIA
We do have a beach, but it's really far west.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
I'm like, this is California. I thought, where's the beach? Like come to Berkeley, and it's quite pleasant.
You know the experience I had my first day on campus at Berkeley, I was staying with a host family in Orinda, so I took the boat to Rockridge and walked up — DAN GARCIA: Telegraph.
KRSTE ASANOVIC: — Telegraph to come into camp — I walked up — DAN GARCIA: College? KRSTE ASANOVIC: — College to come into campus, and I was walking up.
There's all these guys with long hair, or 60s clothes. And the whole street was light. I'm thinking, wow, Berkeley really is in the 60s. I have to grow my hair long.
Now I have. [INAUDIBLE] This is really in the '60s. What I didn't realize was The Grateful Dead were playing at the Greek.
DAN GARCIA
Oh!
KRSTE ASANOVIC
My first day on campus, this is what I saw.
DAN GARCIA
What's that smell?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
That was my introduction to Berkeley. My first day on campus.
DAN GARCIA
Wow.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
It's a Grateful Dead concert. So I got to campus, obviously, had a great time. Learned a lot, but I must say coming to America from the UK, my first impression was, Americans are crazy.
They work way too hard. And I was a TA for 60c, which was the predecessor of 61c [INAUDIBLE].
DAN GARCIA
Right. That's right.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So I actually was a TA for this class when Paul Hilfinger was the teacher.
DAN GARCIA
Wow!
KRSTE ASANOVIC
First semester. And I just remember how hard everybody worked. I'm sure it's exactly the same now. I know it's exactly the same now.
But I was thinking, these undergrads are doing in one semester what, in Cambridge, you would do over a year.
DAN GARCIA
Wow.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
[INAUDIBLE] And you were taking three other classes too. How great these Americans are. All my other foreign students I was hanging out with, they're like the same, these Americans are nuts.
But after a few months, we were all nuts too. I'm working just as hard.
DAN GARCIA
Sure.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So we got into it. That was exciting. Oh, one other thing happened. That first semester I was here was when the big earthquake hit.
So Loma Prieta hit during a 60c class.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, my goodness.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
I had to transcribe the notes, and the video included the earthquake right in the middle of the — DAN GARCIA: Look at that. 1990? Yeah.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
1989.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, yeah. That's right. 1989, that's right, '89.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So I did my PhD, and I worked on, actually building accelerators for neural network training, which is kind of funny, because it's what people are into right now.
But back then, this was a new thing with Nelson Morgan at Pixie.
DAN GARCIA
Yes, indeed. I know Nelson well.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So we did speech recognition. I built machines to help people run speech recognition faster. So that was the last wave of neural nets. I built a vector process.
And this is part of the experience that led to [INAUDIBLE] five. So we built a few chips by the team there. We went. We did several different chip designs, and they kind of worked.
It slowly built up our expertise in building chips, and we put some processes. And then I decided that way before in the process is kind of chunky.
We should use a standard instruction set and get all the software to make everything work.
And so, okay, we'll put a MIPS processor and extend it with a vector unit, which is what we did.
But we went to talk to MIPS, the company, and said, we'd like to build the MIPS core. And they said, sure, go ahead. We'll give you a license.
Okay, great. They said $2 million, back in 1992. And that was real dollars. So we're like, oh, no, we can't do that.
We can't.
DAN GARCIA
Not so much. Not so much.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
I just came back to Berkeley and said, oh, I'll just build my own MIPS core. All that we would have gotten for that $2 million would be their blessing and some test factors.
DAN GARCIA
Right.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
There was no soft core industry or anything at that time. [INAUDIBLE] Log was still a new thing. People were just learning how to synthesize from [INAUDIBLE] Log.
Remember working with the Berkeley CAD researchers, Ellen Sentovich, and she's working on a synthesis tool, and I was using early versions of that to do the synthesis for this chip.
So it's very early days. very early days. So anyway, we just ignored MIPS, and I just built my own MIPS core from scratch.
But that was one of the formative things for RISC-V is like, why do we pay these guys so much money for basically a list of alt codes? Didn't make any sense at all, right?
Yeah, we built this vector thing. It was a big success. We actually shipped it to nine sites around the world, and the people used it for training, actually training.
You know, so then that was my PhD. Then it was like, what to do next? I decided it's one of those things.
Going all the way through grad school, I didn't know if I wanted to be a professor, or I'll go work in industry. I'll be a professor.
Go with industry, and I must have gone back and forth about 10 times.
There was one point we were going to do a startup with Creative Labs sound blaster eyes because this vector chip, it turned out, Dave Wessel [INAUDIBLE] ported all this music synthesis software to it, so that was a thought.
But then I thought, no. I need to get my PhD. I need to get — well, one thing, I needed a green card.
I also wanted to actually get a PhD, so I finished that. Then I went off to MIT. So what happened was I didn't even apply to MIT.
They called me up because they — come and interview. I didn't really want to go to MIT. I didn't think so until I got there, and I thought oh, this is a cool place.
Went to MIT's faculty, then — DAN GARCIA: We got your back.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Got me back, yeah. So the weather got me back. Basically, I loved MIT, but Boston — I couldn't stand the weather. And the West Coast — and also the industry here.
You have all the industry here. That really pulled me back, so — DAN GARCIA: For those who don't know, by the way, there are levels of impressiveness.
And there's like, well, I applied to MIT.
I had to fight my way, and I got in as you know — no, there's a level above that, which is they call you, and that's what happened to Krste.
It's a whole 'nother level here. That's great.
BORA NIKOLIC
We got a few questions from students in here that say — here is one. Is this the same person who authored the RISC-V specification?
I don't know if I would have done my project without that, laughing out loud. So are you the same person?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Yes, with help from, especially, Andrew Waterman, who was my grad student. He's now a graduate. He also wrote a lot of the original spec as well.
BORA NIKOLIC
We had him, also, here. He was in here.
DAN GARCIA
That was fun. That was fun.
BORA NIKOLIC
So we have — then Adrian says did you have to write programs in assembly language, or were there any languages you could program in that was related to your Acorn computer?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Oh, no. So you know back then, BASIC was the thing everybody — DAN GARCIA: BASIC, yeah, that's right.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
All computers had BASIC and ROM, and the whole programming language fit in 2 kilobytes of ROM, right? So you imagine you've got to write a whole interpreter that fits in 2 kilobytes.
Yes, we used BASIC and assembly.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, I mean, I had Sinclair Spectrum, and I got very quickly frustrated with BASIC so I ran a ton of assembly at that time.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
It's a good video game.
BORA NIKOLIC
Not much after that. Not much after that.
DAN GARCIA
What's funny is there's a whole generation of us.
We're all about a couple of years away from each other, actually, and I started in BASIC in a TRS 80, so all of us had the same experience and also fell in love with video games, as well.
A third question, is 152 more like the courses in EE16 series or 61C? The person says, I personally greatly prefer how topics such as circuits are approached in 61C over 16B.
Are any of the more advanced mathematical topics from 16B needed as well? This is for 152.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So 152 is more like 61C, and it's actually more about architecture and software, so there's very little on the circuit or even logic design level.
If you want the logic design experience, you should take 151, but 152 is more architecture and interactions with software.
DAN GARCIA
And their question is, if I'm enjoying 61C but didn't really enjoy 16B, should I still take 152? And it sounds like yes.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Yes, yes. Like it more.
BORA NIKOLIC
Guys — secret. I don't enjoy 16B either.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, oh, boy. Oh, boy. I should have paused the recording. What are you doing here?
Come on. I can edit that out in post.
BORA NIKOLIC
Oh, they know. I've been vocal about this.
DAN GARCIA
I'll edit in post. I'll edit in post. It's okay.
BORA NIKOLIC
I've been vocal about this.
DAN GARCIA
It's still — it's a course in development. We're still working on it. This is great.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So you recommend 152 for students who are planning to pursue a career in software.
DAN GARCIA
Oh yeah, you can see the questions too, yeah.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
You're working on low level software like compilers or operating systems, like deep, heavy performance — high performance software, definitely.
152 will help you understand how to make a machine run fast and to be able to understand all the features.
BORA NIKOLIC
What industries do you see as a future for RISC-V?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Everything, eventually. It's all a matter of time scale. So right now embedded in IoT, very good for RISC-V. I think you'll be surprised at how soon phones are going to switch to RISC-V.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, interesting.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
It's going to happen a lot sooner than anybody thinks. A lot of interest there. Servers are probably the last thing that switches over. There's a lot of interest in mobile right now.
So the recent — one thing that's happened is this recent acquisition of Arm by NVIDIA has really, really accelerated interest in RISC-V. So many of the companies who had been developing project RISC-V, a lot of the big ones have been.
Now they're really, really planning to move completely to RISC-V. What are some places — [INAUDIBLE] I never taught 16B.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, I never taught 16B.
BORA NIKOLIC
Neither me, but we probably need to.
DAN GARCIA
I'll let you go first, Bora. Enjoy it.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
What are some places where people are switching to RISC-V and monitoring?
So a lot of what we call minion cores — so a lot of these big chips, when you build a big chip like your smartphone or even the laptop processor, there's the big core that everybody knows about, like the x86 or the Arm, but there's also like dozens of other little processors on those SOC's.
And those are the places that people are switching those from what they are currently are over to RISC-V. Another area where we're seeing a lot of activities is in storage controllers like SSD drives, so a big company like Western Digital announced they're switching everything over to RISC-V.
They ship billions of devices. They're paying a lot in royalties on those cores. They're very keen to move to RISC-V. Also, they can customize it.
So disc SSDs have custom ECC, error control, and compression algorithms, and they build extensions that optimize those, so that's another area.
AI accelerators, all the startups building AI stuff using RISC-V, network processors, so a lot of things around service people are moving to RISC-V.
And it's sort of all the little cores are currently moving, but like I said, mobile is probably the next big area you're going to see RISC-V show up.
DAN GARCIA
Good stuff.
BORA NIKOLIC
So I have a question, then we'll let you go. We have some other logistical things. So the [INAUDIBLE] is this PC-like platform that is RISC-V based.
I think it will be spectacular to move all of our 61C labs to that. Then we go from the beginning until the end, right?
Stay in RISC-V. Don't have to switch our x86 — DAN GARCIA: X86 who?
BORA NIKOLIC
How painful — how painful is that going to be, or how ready is this platform?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
I think it's very — BORA NIKOLIC: This year or next year?
KRSTE ASANOVIC
So one thing, you're going to see many, many, many more dev boards come out next year.
There's a lot of silicon in flight right now, so I think it'll be picking the right dev board. But definitely, yeah.
I think the good thing is it's a very open environment, so you have to worry about binary blobs and everything, so students can see all the source code all the way down, like from boot all the way through.
I think that would be a good part of the experience, and the match board could be fine. It runs AMD GPUs because they released open drivers so you can see the source code.
So I think it will be good for the students because all the code is open.
All the interfaces are open, so they can get in and actually see — from the very — from the minute you reset, everything that happens to bring the machine up.
So I think that would be very good for people to understand. That's one of the standard interview questions. When you hit reset on my computer, what happens?
So your goal for the students there should be to actually understand everything that happens from reset onwards bringing up the system.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, that's great.
BORA NIKOLIC
There are two quick questions. Can we get quick one liners? Are there any parts of the RISC-V I see — KRSTE ASANOVIC: That you want to do differently or disagree with.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yes, that you would want to do differently or disagree with with 5 years or 10 years of observation.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
There's already annoying things that we put in there, like, we wish we did differently, but they're not that big a problem.
We know the problems, but they're not really a big — they're not worth starting again.
The other thing you realize, as soon as you build an ISA, you kind of get stuck with legacy and you have to just work with what you decided to do before, and part of the craft of an architect is actually working with legacy.
That's what you have to do.
Construction sites live for like 50 years, and so you have to think — no matter how far ahead you think, you always get something wrong once you consider something some new constraint or some new thing that comes along.
So yeah, there's lots of things I would change — well, a few things I would change, nothing major. Nothing that makes me think we should start again. No way.
But yeah, disagree with?
No, I've agreed with everything so far having been involved in designing most of it, but there's definitely things we'd like to do differently if we could go again, but we can't, so we just keep building.
If you switch to Linux PC's — the last question, if you switch to Linux PC's, will we not need to assimilate RISC-V in Venus and instead run it locally?
Yeah, if it's running on a real RISC-V natively, you don't need to simulate, though the simulator gives you more observability.
You may want to simulate it so you can trace, and debug, and do things, and see what's going on better than running on the actual hardware.
DAN GARCIA
But actually, relative to what's happening tomorrow, there's a call for open hardware, open software for our voting machines.
So you can imagine some future where, based on this open [INAUDIBLE] architecture, you can see all the way down.
Here's a voting machine, and if you want to tear it apart, there's nothing that would be proprietary, so you could imagine a future that might involve that.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Yeah, there is actually government grants for RISC-V. There's people building voting machines around RISC-V.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, that's wonderful. Thank you for doing that, good stuff. Thank you so much. Let's give Krste a hand.
Thank you so much.
BORA NIKOLIC
Thank you, Krste.
KRSTE ASANOVIC
Thanks for inviting me over.
DAN GARCIA
Great to see you. Thank you again for here. It's funny how close our connection was. We both were grad students here at Berkeley together.
It's funny that you were on the — I was on the fifth floor doing graphics.
You were on the fourth floor probably with Randy, and Dave, and all that, and it's funny how we all ending up together.
BORA NIKOLIC
And last week we had Tom Burns in here, and I think he took that class in '89 [INAUDIBLE].. He's [INAUDIBLE] Senior Fellow now. All right.
DAN GARCIA
Good stuff. Thanks again, Krste.
BORA NIKOLIC
Thank you, thanks.
DAN GARCIA
Good to see you, my friend. All right, very good. All right, so we're back here. Let's talk about some computing in the news.
Let's see. I removed Krste from the list. There, Okay. All right, so go ahead.
Sci-Fi, [INAUDIBLE]. Go ahead. Do your thing.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, do we have energy to unveil a Linux PC based on RISC-V processors? Are we ready to ship the labs? Can we get going and switch over the labs?
DAN GARCIA
I mean, it turns out that it took a grant, I believe. It was either a grant, or somebody had money to buy the hive, so we're going to need some equivalent thing.
And he kept talking about a dev board, so it may be that we have to have a fully debugged machine that can drop [INAUDIBLE] dev board.
BORA NIKOLIC
This thing, you plug in — I mean, by looking at what is in there, you plug in the supply, network, and a keyboard, then monitor, and it goes.
DAN GARCIA
Right, you can imagine a model where we could see what the horsepower of this thing is, whether it can support all the users who are going to be using it, but — BORA NIKOLIC: No, no, no.
We need, probably, a couple hundred of these.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, I know. This feels very Raspberry Pi-like. It feels like we can have a lot of them. It doesn't look that expensive.
A lot of them, and then hook them up to a big network, and then just log into — maybe actually put them in the machine room, to be honest, a headless set that you could check remotely.
I love that idea, but it might take a grant to make it happen.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, yeah. I mean, they're not that terribly expensive, I think. I mean, it's going to be quite a bit of a development, 600 something bucks.
DAN GARCIA
Right, 665, yeah.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, that's going to — but you need supplies, and monitors, and stuff like that.
DAN GARCIA
For hobbyists and engineers. Yeah, it is basically a much faster, much better produced Raspberry Pi, essentially, right? It looks like this.
You get exactly that, and you have to then wire it together, and put a casing around it, if anything. All right, I'm looking at four minutes left, and we got some things to cover.
It's exciting. That's good stuff. That's some good stuff. Let's do a quickie schedule check in.
We're at week 11. We're at lecture 29, Monday. We're basically a new topic. You want to, Bora, introduce it, mentioning this is a whole new reset from lectures again?
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, so every few weeks in this semester we kind of, in this class, we get a fresh start.
So we are now — on Friday, we started the module that deals with the operating system support virtual memory and IO, so it builds up on a lot of stuff that we have talked about.
It covers some of these questions that Krste mentioned.
What happens to the computer when you press the power switch, and it starts booting, and you realize you don't have a keyboard. It's not connected, and so on.
So we cover some of that. This [INAUDIBLE] material is — you actually don't need too much of it for the project 4.
It does help understanding generally how things work, but it is — we have a homework that is and that does cover that material.
And there are labs that are helpful as, again, as we said from last week, the labs are optional, and we covered it, yeah.
So that is essentially what we have with us, and then we are going into parallelism next week, so things are moving fairly fast. Parallelism is covered by project 4.
DAN GARCIA
Right, perfect, perfect. There was a question. Are 2 homeworks do next Monday? I thought we collapsed 2 homework into 1 to say they're both due at the same time.
BORA NIKOLIC
No, we moved two of them.
DAN GARCIA
Right, but it looks here on the schedule — BORA NIKOLIC: Yeah, we moved one of them. We postponed it, yeah.
DAN GARCIA
The schedule may not have revealed it because it says 8 is due 11/9 9 is due 11/16. I think we actually ended up moving 8 to 9's due date.
Isn't that right? But we didn't update the website. I thought that's what he had done, so we'll make sure to fix the website on that one.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, I think there are two that are due next week because we moved one that was due last Friday.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, we didn't want to have anything also due this week either, so that's another concern we've been bringing that this — who knows what could happen tomorrow?
We've talked about this in other classes trying to — if there might be protests. There might be chaos.
We hope that everything's peaceful whatever ends up happening, but we don't know, so we're all trying to — most people are not having classes anything due on Tuesday and giving you some time to vote if you need the time, and try to remove the assignments this week, so we're trying to push these out a little bit to give some some freedom of that.
All right, let's do some more.
This is the last slide with a minute or two here left, and I can also say a little bit later, Bor, if people want to ask questions and answer them.
Okay, so there was a — we tried to get the midterm auto graders done, but we're actually backed up. We're still working on the quest retake auto graders, and that's happened.
We basically have a small inner core team who does these things, and they're working on that one because that's the quest retake, so we're good on that one.
So the midterm auto graders, which are the ones that affects everybody, they're still being worked on.
We were planning on having a midterm retake this weekend, but we may delay this, and part of that is normally what we do is we look at the grades before, and then we make some decisions about who needs to take it based on that.
It's not just a blind thing. It's about — it factors their grades in as well. There always were questions about, do we need to take it for the whole exam, and no.
You never need to take it for the whole exam, only for the sections you had technical problems on.
Oh, I had some trouble in section 3, the one I started with, and then the camera fell, but then I figured out how to plug it in and not have the fall, and so then everything else is fine.
Well, then it's only needed for section 3. You might need to do it. It's not a guarantee. We might actually waive it, so that's the plan.
So we may end up having to delay the retake this weekend so that we have all the grades in to know who would need to take it, so it's not like if — we just don't want to make people have to do more work than they had to and sometimes we'll just take the grade.
If it depends, we'll have to read all the quotes. Well, the video went off for three seconds. Well, probably three seconds is okay.
Well, it went out for five minutes, went out for 20 minutes.
How long — so there's a kind of a soft edge on this, and we have to make some calls there, and I've made that call last time.
BORA NIKOLIC
And I forgot to submit the video.
DAN GARCIA
Yeah, exactly. I forgot. Well, [INAUDIBLE].
Project 4 does launch this week, so that's the exciting one that we need some of the material for this week to launch, and here's the — there was a question that came up, by the way, I should mention.
There is a group of students who are organizing representatives to come meet with us in our staff meeting on Wednesdays. Please do respond to that Piazza post.
I didn't link it here, but there's a Piazza post where people were saying fill in this form, and we'll have a meeting, and we'll kind of choose some folks.
We'll have a rotating group of students to come visit us. That'd be great to get feedback from everybody.
If you want to be one of those students, please fill in that form, and talk to those students, and then get yourself on the list to come meet with us.
One of the things — one of the questions that came up during that important meeting we had last week — and I want to thank the students for doing that — was you've made some homework optional.
Is it really optional? And we certainly want to say it 100% is optional. What that means by making it optional is that it's good for you. It's like eating your broccoli.
You can survive without eating your broccoli that meal if you want to eat something that doesn't have any green vegetables in it. That's okay.
You probably survive, but it's better for you to eat broccoli. That's what this.
This is good for you, but you will survive it, which means on the exam, the material from — I believe it's homework 9/11 — Bor, if you want to correct me on that.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, 9/11 are the ones that are optional, yeah.
DAN GARCIA
And so that means that material from the homework will not be on exam. In a way I say whatever material on the exam around that material will be from lecture, okay?
So if you don't do the homework at all, you can get a perfect score on the exam. Does that make — I'll say it again.
If you don't do the homework, you can still be able to answer the questions based on attending the lecture, understanding it from there and moving forward.
There'll be nothing directly from the homework that you had only seen from the homework we'll be assessing.
There might be overlapping if it's on the homework and on the lecture, well then we can test it because on the lecture, but nothing only from the homework that's not on the lecture will we test, if that makes sense.
BORA NIKOLIC
And just to make sure, I mean, we went carefully through the material of the classes that depend on us on 61C, and homework 8, if you don't do it, if you don't retain any of that material on virtual memory, you're not going to have any good time in 152 or 162, so you need to take this one.
I mean, yeah, yeah. That's not going to work. But homeworks 9 and 11, I think those are reasonably cover from scratch and anywhere else where they depend on us.
DAN GARCIA
And there was also — so there was two questions. So the labs truly optional, like homework, what we're going to say is the labs are a place for you to learn the material deeper.
So the labs are things where the labs are not being checked off. You're not being graded for them, but the material — this is important.
We're distinguishing what we did with the labs with the homework. Homework, again, you don't have to do it. You can ace the exam. I would say, not true for the labs.
I would say you need to go through the labs to learn them to do that. What's different is you don't have to do the labs that week.
That was the difference, and you don't ever have to show us at all. If you went through the labs and eventually learned the material, that's going to show up on the exam.
The labs are not optional. It's a good question to ask. The labs are not optional in terms of the material is still covered. That material is a great exercise.
It's great practice, and that is going to be then tested. So it's not going to say, well, what did we do on the lab page 14?
We won't do that, but to learn the material in a deeper, richer way, that then would be there. So it's not something you have to — oh, my gosh.
There's 19 things due this week. No, relax it. It's not something you have — you never need to show us. We just know, but we encourage you to do it.
We encourage you to ask questions to your TAs and to your staff about it, but we're never going to force you to do it by a deadline, but that material is still on exams.
Again, never directly from what's on line 14, but that material is how you go deeper into the material, and maybe an example, caches.
There'll be some problems on caches you'll do in labs, and there might be an exam question that's very similar or not at all similar, but you are learning about caches there, and caches are certainly on the exam, so that's the idea.
So labs are truly optional in the sense of not having to show us anything, but the material is covered, unlike homeworks where that material isn't covered. The lecture will be fine.
That's all you need for for this. And if we're not sure if we need to do a midterm retake, should we expect an email soon?
There's only emails I'm going to wait for it This is why I think we might need to be delaying the midterm retake is we need to be looking at student's grades, and how they did, and whether they need to do it again.
And I need to be reading — I need to take the time to read all the little, something went wrong, and I read about it, and I make a judgment call.
I did that for every single person who wrote something, and they failed, and they need to do this again for again 1,000 people.
So that's a lot of reading and a lot of stuff, and it might need — and for the questions what took so long was we had to get all the grades in, then I had to read everybody, then cross correlate them to decide who's doing it.
And then once I give the list, I give you one more chance to say, well, I'm not on the list or I shouldn't be on — I should either — should be on the list or should not be on the list to find out what the final list.
Is all that took about four weeks, so we're hoping the midterm doesn't delay that much, but it looks like that's where we're all leaning, but we want to make a final call.
We'll let you know soon about whether that's going to happen. That's the place, okay? Shoo. Thank you all.
What a good day. I'm glad we had Sharon, Krste.
That was a great — that was a great set of visits, good stuff, and it went long, but we actually didn't have any more than this.
This is my last slide before we have our little ask us anything. I hope everybody had a safe Halloween, by the way. I didn't go anywhere, but we dressed up.
Our family was the characters from Among Us. I don't know, Bora. Did your family do anything for Halloween? But it was lots of fun.
Yeah, you're muted. It was a good time.
BORA NIKOLIC
I muted myself because my son is practicing piano in the other room.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, okay. That's okay.
BORA NIKOLIC
We didn't do anything, I mean, really. My son went and they had closed court trick and treating, five houses organized.
DAN GARCIA
Oh, little houses. That's nice. Yeah, small thing.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
DAN GARCIA
That's great.
BORA NIKOLIC
So it was all set up. No surprises over there.
DAN GARCIA
My uncle went — my uncle lives in New York and he bought — he showed on Facebook — he bought hundreds of pieces of candy, wrapped them all.
He zip locks, sprayed and wiped them all down. He had 200 things ready for all the kids. 10 people came by. He had 200 things to give away.
Nobody came. It's a little crazy, but people are staying safe. I'm glad people are staying safe. That is that's the right call, I think.
It's just hard for younger kids, I think. All right, folks, this is a good week. Go ahead, go ahead. Finish up, go ahead.
BORA NIKOLIC
We have — so next week, visitors are from Apple, so get your questions ready, and I think if we are ready, they may give out some prizes. We'll find out.
It depends on us, how if we can get the grading done.
DAN GARCIA
That's exciting, good stuff, and then just a little — BORA NIKOLIC: But ask them about any internships and stuff like that back then, jobs, whatever you need.
DAN GARCIA
Wonderful, wonderful, and also next week we close up VM and we start TLP thread level processing, so we'll talk about that next week, and we'll talk about threads and how to do things in parallel.
That'll set you up very well for your project 4. One last word, your vote counts. Please do vote, folks. We put it on the first slide.
We're putting it on every slide in the top right. Please do vote if you haven't, and good luck to all of us.
BORA NIKOLIC
Especially if you are outside of California It's worth a lot more than our votes.
DAN GARCIA
That's a good point. That's a good point. Yes, indeed, good stuff. All right, folks.
BORA NIKOLIC
All right.
DAN GARCIA
Take care. Bora's son is going to take us off with a little piano etude to take us home here.
BORA NIKOLIC
Yeah, right. Thank you.
DAN GARCIA
Good stuff, everybody. Take care, folks.
BORA NIKOLIC
Bye, bye.
DAN GARCIA
All right, bye bye, now.
BORA NIKOLIC
Bye.
Đăng nhập để đánh giá học liệu này.
Đăng nhập để bình luận — chưa ai bình luận về học liệu này.
Không có khóa học liên quan.